Jonathan Takiff: From big screen to small, comin' at ya: Ready or not, it's 3-D TV
With 3-D adventures like "Avatar" and Tim Burton's "Alice in Wonderland" burning it up at the box office, consumer-electronics firms have reason to feel optimistic about their new high-definition 3-D TVs also winning favor, fast
And over the last couple of weeks, leading set-makers Samsung, Panasonic and Sony have been jockeying furiously for position with marketing and promotional movesTheir goal is to be "first in mind" when consumers decide to take the plunge
WHO'S GOT THE GOODS (AND THE HYPE)?: Samsung and Panasonic heralded the availability of their first 3-D sets with events in New York last week
And, while Sony won't have 3-D TVs for sale until June, the company has already put pre-production samples on display at its Sony Style stores
The Panasonic event at Best Buy's Union Square location was relatively low key - celebrating the sale of the first, $3,000 3-D home-theater system: a 50-inch plasma screen and a 3-D-capable Blu-ray player with a couple of pairs of those gotta wear 'em, active-shutter glassesFor the next three or four months, the Magnolia Home Theater departments inside Best Buy stores are the only locales where you'll be able to see and buy these products
OK, I take that backPanasonic also is putting a new products caravan on the road, spotlighting 3-DThe portable showroom stops at the King of Prussia Mall, March 25-27
Early buyers of Panny 3-D sets will get a free copy of Fox's "Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs," the first Full HD 3-D Blu-ray movie to go on sale next monthLater in the year, the offering may switch to 3-D titles like "Coraline" or (be still my heart) "Avatar," which Panasonic promoted heavily before its opening(The 2-D DVD and Blu-ray versions of "Avatar" go on sale April 22.)
You'll also see Panasonic alligned as sponsor of DirecTV's trio of 3-D channels launching in June
SAMSUNG EXPERIENCE: While already available online at Amazon.com (and coming soon to Sears and Best Buy), Samsung spent two days and big bucks celebrating the release of its first two (of 17!) 3-D LCD- and Plasma-based modelsThe festivities capped with a Times Square mini-concert by the Black Eyed Peas, then a celebrity strewn party at the Samsung Experience
"Avatar" director James Cameron was hired to shoot the Peas in 3-D (take that Panasonic!)The footage will doubtless play on Samsung sets at retail to lure in gawkersSamsung also shot the Red Carpet parade at the Academy Awards in 3-D, for more exclusive showroom content, I'm guessingAnd this leading TV brand has made a deal with Dreamworks Animation to be the exclusive distributor of "Monsters vsAliens" and (later in the year) the "Shrek" series on 3-D Blu-ray discs to buyers of Samsung 3-D ensemblesThat's clout
SONY'S PITCH: Sony Style stores are showing off on demo sets its sister studio's one and only 3-D movie of note, "Cloudy With A Chance of Meatballs," and will probably toss in the title with a gear purchase
And, ironically, you'll see Sony sponsoring 3-D cable/satellite-fed events even before the company's sets go on sale - starting with Masters golf rounds April 7-11, which Comcast will show, then the first FIFA World Cup soccer game (June 11), premiering on the ESPN 3D special-events channelSony's also co-sponsoring a Discovery 3-D natural history channel, but it won't launch til 2011
WHO DOES 3-D BEST?: While all these new-generation TVs have the goods to decipher 3-D-encoded Blu-ray discs and channels served up by cable and satellite providers, a seasoned eye may detect differences in picture quality
Panasonic claims that the high-speed "sub-field" switching and faster-refreshing pixels in its 3-D plasma sets are better suited than LCD technology to the rigors of stereoscopic displayFor sure, the pictures popping out of Panny demo models looked awesome
Then again, so were the images that Samsung put up on its first LED edge-lit LCD sets, which deploy a technology called "black frame insertion" to sharpen viewers' perception of the picture
Ah, but those Sony prototype LCD 3-D sets are not ready for prime timeIn some "Cloudy" scenes I sensed a strobing effect that would surely induce headaches and drive me mad over timeAnd none of the 3-D effects really jumped out in front of the screenOther challenging content originally part of the Sony Style demo - including clips from the PS3 videogame "Wipeout 3D" and some soccer match footage - was judged so harshly by online reviewer Gary Merson (HDGuru.com) that Sony has stopped showing itGiven the big push that Sony Computer Entertainment is planning for 3-D PS3 titles as a "game changer" separating the system from the Wii and Xbox 360, those demo eliminations, albeit temporary, have got to be painful
WHAT'S THIS GOING TO COST?: As high-end sets that also do very well with 2-D content, the first 3-D TVs won't be cheapSamsung's LCD line starts with a conventionally backlit (CCFL) 46-inch LN46C750 priced at $1699, and a 50-inch plasma (PN50C700) at $1799Panasonic's least expensive TC-50VT20 and similar TC-P50VT25 plasmas are in the $2,500-$2,600 rangeThen you've got to buy extra pairs of the battery-powered shutter glasses, as only one pair comes with a setPanny's go for $149 each, while Samsung's are priced at $129 to $179 for a version with a rechargeable battery(The battery in non-recharging models is rated for 50 to 100 hours of use.)
Complicating matters, first-generation shutter glasses are brand-specificSo you'll want sports-viewing and game-playing pals to buy the same brand of 3-D TV and specs, or the latter won't work on your set
Sony can save you some coin if you buy the maker's first "3-D upgradeable" Blu-ray player (BDP-S470) now available for $199, or 3-D-ready (soon) PlayStation 3 game console (starting at $299), compared with the $399 tag that Samsung and Panasonic put on their first 3-D Blu-ray playersThe Panny at least has two HDMI output jacks on its DMP-BDT300/350 models -- the second for streaming high-def audio to a recent receiver that won't pass through 3-D video